What is a Barrel Pick?
A private single barrel selected for flavor and bottled in limited quantity—often impossible to find again.
A whiskey selected from a single barrel chosen for its standout flavor, character, and quality. Instead of buying a standard batch blended from many barrels, we taste through individual barrels and choose the one that deserves to be bottled on its own.
Every barrel is different. Even whiskey from the same distillery, same mash bill, and same age can taste completely unique depending on where it aged and how it developed over time. We want you to come with us to the distilleries, sample through unique barrels and pick the ones you think the group should select. Those bottles will go on sale to our members for direct purchase via this site.
One-of-a-Kind
Every barrel is different.
Limited Time
Once it's gone, it's gone.
Chosen by You
Members decide what is worthy.
Single Barrel
No batch blending, no duplicates.
The Bottles That Started It All
Picked on a beautiful end of summer day back in '24 and bottled just before Christmas that year.
1. Starlight Double Oak Bourbon - Legacy barrel - 5 Year - 116.2 Proof
2. Starlight Light Whiskey - Additional VDN Finish - 8.5 Year - 129.5 Proof
3. Starlight Honey Finish Bourbon - Kelvin Char #3 - 5.5 Year - 115.7 Proof
4. Starlight VDN Finish Bourbon - 5.5 Year - 109.9 Proof
Our Charity Pick To Support AFTD
Picked with friends and family in January '25 and bottled in June, in support of a great charity that means a lot to us.
This pick helped directly support The Association for Frontotemporal Degeneration and their mission to fund research, raise awareness, and support families impacted by frontotemporal degeneration.
Starlight Straight Bourbon - 4 Year - 120.4 Proof
Back For Round 3
During the bottle release for charity pick in July '25, our entire family helped to select these four amazing bottles that we picked up for Repeal Day.
1. Starlight Rum Finished Bourbon - Additional Sauternes Finish - 6 Year - 115.9 Proof
2. Starlight Double Oak Bourbon - French Oak - 8 Year - 119.8 Proof
3. Starlight Double Oak Bourbon - French Oak - 8 Year - 120.3 Proof (Bottles used for AFTD donations)
4. Starlight Applejack Brandy - 4.5 Year - 120.2 Proof (Limited run single barrel selection)
5. Starlight Wheat Whiskey - Coming soon!
